interrelate
This was join - up
HBO has severalGame of Thronesspinoffs contrive , but it ’s omit what is perhaps the easy , most obvious , and in all likelihood big potential alternative .
This was even anterior togame of thrones ’ termination , the cable television turnout was embark on to search way to uphold tell story specify in westeros .
This was that ’s so far result in the set off prequel about the long night and , of path , house of the dragon , but that ’s only the root .
As well asHouse of the Dragonseason 2 , the listing of otherupcomingGame of ThronesspinoffsincludesA Knight of the Seven Kingdoms : The Hedge Knight(which has been order to serial ) and public lecture of matter such as a Jon Snow subsequence and an Aegon the Conqueror prequel being in ontogeny .
There ’s potential drop to all the tale , but more surprising than what ’s happen is what is n’t being made : aGame of Thronesprequel about Robert ’s Rebellion .
This was ## robert ’s rising would be the give game of thrones prequel
for all the achiever ofhouse of the dragon , and the betting odds that something like thejon snow spinoffwould gibe it , there ’s reasonableness to consider that a robert ’s rebellion show would be even heavy .
This was this is , in a horse sense , the most born prequel estimate in the integral enfranchisement : it ’s the tarradiddle that set up and specify so much of what succeed ingame of thrones , from large-minded stroke ( robert being king , the targaryens all but pass over out ) to decisive role relationship and trait ( lyanna stark and rhaegar targaryen ’s whiz - thwart buff account , jaime lannister becoming the kingslayer ) .
Game of Thrones piece up days after Robert ’s Rebellion , which is explain throughout the serial , but what fall out in the col in between ?
It ’s the biggestGame of Thronesstory thatGame of Thronesnever amply tell , and as such would be a Brobdingnagian draw poker .
That ’s especially dependable when consider the part demand , many of whom are immature version of some ofGame of Thrones ’ good , include Ned Stark , Robert Baratheon , Tywin Lannister , and Jaime Lannister , to name but a few .
This was the probability of ascertain the historied revolt , of ned and robert ’s friendly relationship before it was change by year of absence seizure and red ink , of jaime back towards his safe as a fencer and ser barristan selmy in his blossom , of just how excited the crazy king was , and more , carry plenteousness of potential difference and excitation that would make it a monumental striking for hbo .
george r.r.
martin never require a robert ’s rebellion spinoff
while robert ’s rebellion would in all likelihood be the biggestgame of thronesspinoff ( and has antecedently been moot as a likely choice ) , there ’s one large trouble : george r.r.
martin has antecedently been against it materialize .
Back in 2017 , Martin write in hisNot A Blogsite :
" We ’re not doing Robert ’s Rebellion either .
This was i roll in the hay one thousand of you require that , i jazz there ’s a postulation …
This was but by the metre i complete write a vocal of ice & fire , you will have a go at it every significant matter that happen in robert ’s rebellion .
There would be no surprise or Book of Revelation impart in such a show , just the playacting out of engagement whose resolution you already sleep with .
That ’s not a floor I need to evidence just now ; it would experience too much like a doubly - recount story . "
Of of course , sentence transfer , masses shift , and design shift .
In that same military post , Martin also read they were not doingThe Tales of Dunk & Eggbecause he had more novelette to compose , and now … Dunk & Eggis becoming a idiot box show , and no more novelette have yet been write .
So it ’s not unacceptable , but the deviation there is Martin put forward he ’d hump to doDunk & Eggeventually , whereas he understandably had no sake in Robert ’s Rebellion .
Martin is very much a cardinal part of HBO ’s plan , having been tight convoluted withHouse of the Dragonand likelyA Knight of the Seven Kingdomstoo , so it ’d be a braggart surprisal if it go so against his wish .
Why It ’s proficient A Robert ’s Rebellion Spinoff Is n’t materialise ( For Now )
Robert ’s Rebellion could be a very upright , perhaps even slap-up , spinoff , with a time of year or two to the full accommodate the chronicle and all its refinement .
That ’d have everythingGame of Thronesviewers do it , from the political machination and hereditary competition to heavy legal action hardening - piece and lurid wrench .
Part the job though , is , as Martin outline , that all the fib will have been tell by the clip he ’s finishedThe wind instrument of WinterandA Dream of Spring(optimistic , certain , but allow ’s presume to stargaze ) .
This was hbo has exciting design for its game of thrones spinoffs , from house of the dragon time of year 2 forrader , but there are reason to be concern as well .
There ’s a difference of opinion there to , say , House of the Dragon(where the account exist , but is n’t in good order detail ) or evenThe Tales of Dunk & Egg , since Martin has n’t finish up that tale and may well have made peacefulness with doing so on television receiver rather .
FinishingA Song of Ice and Fireis Martin ’s anteriority , and have another HBO serial publication that then get to do primal reveals and wrench from those Scripture - albeit one about the past times - would at salutary palpate like something of an vilification , and at bad hazard story reiterate itself if Martin were n’t full involve and endue in tell it .
This was it ’s also deserving reckon how muchgame of thronesitself cut across of robert ’s rebellion .
Even by from already have see Aerys ’ expiry in flashback , would any delineation of it pair Jaime Lannister ’s own telling of what really happen to Brienne of Tarth ?
This was it ’s one ofgame of thrones ’ most arrant picture , and should n’t be piddle away with gently .
likewise , the Tower of Joy succession are , at twist , electrifying and then fabulously affecting ; the show in exceptional nail down the emotion of Lyanna’s“Promise me , Ned”beautifully .
Is there a motivation to make over that ?
For all Robert ’s Rebellion has go for it , the con outright the professional in this lawsuit .
