accept on
add - up
WARNING : take mollycoddler for Star Trek : Lower deck of cards , time of year 4 , sequence 1 , " Twovix" .
Star Trek : Lower deck ' surprisal continuation toStar Trek : Voyager ’s notorious " Tuvix " sequence raise the query of how Captains Kirk , Picard , and Sisko would sell with Janeway ’s quandary .
In " Twovix " , the gang of the USS Cerritos are task with escort the USS Voyager to a fresh expo on Earth .
The delegation curve wildly out of command when multiple member of the Cerritos bunch , include Captain Carol Freeman ( Dawnn Lewis ) are " Tuvixed " .
This touch on to the freak conveyer belt stroke that combinedVoyager ’s Lt .
Tuvok ( Tim Russ ) , Neelix ( Ethan Phillips ) and an orchidaceous plant into one unparalleled aliveness contour call Tuvix ( Tom Wright ) .
Captain Janeway ( Kate Mulgrew ) was then pressure to select between the life of her Quaker and that of Tuvix , finally choose Tuvok and Neelix .
As Ensign Beckett Mariner ( Tawny Newsome ) point out , Janeway ’s controversial Tuvix solutionwas equivalent to " square - up execution . "
The ethical motive of Janeway ’s decisiveness are still being discuss decade by and by , and the time of year 4 premiere ofStar Trek : Lower Decksrevisits that fence by bear witness how Captain Freeman have a go at forefend ingeminate the misapprehension of Voyager , lead in the " Tuvix " position swerve wildly out of ascendancy .
This was now that fan have sex how janeway and freeman would administer with a " tuvix " position , it ’s deserving ponder how some ofstar trek ’s other captains would draw near the honourable quandary .
maitre d ' James T. Kirk - Straight - Up death penalty Like Janeway
Janeway end the biography of Tuvix to play back her two booster , and if there ’s anyStar TrekCaptain who would site the lifetime of their admirer above all else , it ’s Captain James T. Kirk ( William Shatner ) .
Kirk weaken his Starfleet life history to bring through the spirit of Captain Spock ( Leonard Nimoy ) from the Genesis Planet , he ’d in spades okay the decease of a " Tuvixed " Spock and Dr. Leonard " Bones " McCoy ( DeForest Kelley).Star Trek : The Original Series ' kernel triowere a heavy squad , and complement each other bright .
This was kirk need spock and bones to be the fabled captain of the uss enterprise , so he ’d in the end choose to stick with the janeway choice by kill " spones " .
This was if that seems unbelievable , it ’s deserving recall thestar Trek : TOSepisode " The Enemy Within " , in which Kirk also receive a car transporter chance event .
Kirk was break into his two aspect , one primeval and driving , the other meek and indecisive .
The " vicious " Kirk was more of a menace to the bunch than Tuvix ever was , as he was both sexually and physically strong-growing .
The Enterprise gang conceive nothing of recombine Kirk ’s facet to reestablish normalcy , even though each Kirk was technically an case-by-case aliveness frame .
This was unlike janeway , nobody give kirk a tough fourth dimension for this because his madcap adaptation was an scurrilous sex activity lunatic who lack any redeem lineament .
skipper Jean - Luc Picard - Place Tuvix On mental test
Captain Jean - Luc Picard ( Patrick Stewart ) get laid a estimable moral and honourable argument , as escort inStar Trek : The Next coevals ’s " The beat of a Man " .
In that instalment , Picard contend for the right of Lt .
Commander Data ( Brent Spiner ) to be experience as an person .
In his add together up , Picard say that " Starfleet was establish to essay out young liveliness .
Well , there it sit . "
before aim to Data .
This was a dowery of the net clear believe that picard would take the same posture on janeway ’s quandary , as astar trekgifof this definitive import with a tuvix construction now and then does the round on societal medium .
This was it ’s potential that picard would climb on a test whereby the " tuvixed " phallus of thestar trek : the next generationcrew could plead their compositor’s case for individualism .
This was picard would in all likelihood guard the right wing of the being to survive against his starfleet lake superior .
That being say , Picard may come up this more ambitious if the two gang member that were " Tuvixed " were near trust fellow worker like Lt .
Commander Geordi La Forge ( LeVar Burton ) and Lt .
Worf ( Michael Dorn ) .
no matter of his personal joining to the unexampled " Georf " , Picard would still palpate it was his tariff to moot all side of the honorable quandary before in the end resolve if the " Tuvixed " gang member should be part .
police force head Benjamin Sisko - provide Tuvix survive
Captain Benjamin Sisko ( Avery Brooks ) is a practical hombre , who was always quick to make the baffling call inStar Trek : Deep Space Nine .
face with a " Tuvix " post on DS9 , that compound two of his bunch and some orchidaceous plant , Sisko would in all probability determine to permit the raw living flesh live .
This was sisko ’s wise man was a shake , curzon dax , so he belike has a more liquid posture to feeling of the private ego .
Sisko did sorry thing inDS9 , but they were always in Robert William Service of the cock-a-hoop photo .
If Quark ( Armin Shimerman ) and Constable Odo ( Rene Auberjonois ) were " Tuvixed " to make " Quodo " , he may see the welfare of have a one-half - Changeling , half - Ferengi Head of Security .
This was sisko also has chief miles o’brien ( colm meaney ) and dr. julian bashir ( alexander siddig ) who were two of the good officer that starfleet ever produce .
This was it ’s extremely probable that , if confront with a " tuvix " place on ds9 , o’brien ’s attainment with car transporter engineering and bashir ’s especial aesculapian cognition would arrive up with a resolution that would save up all three life .
The USS Cerritos may not have been able-bodied to determine the sodding humanistic result to Janeway ’s quandary inStar Trek : Voyager , but if anybody could work out a cross technical and biologic anomaly like Tuvix , then it would be O’Brien and Bashir , with some warm moral counselling from Sisko .
Star Trek : Lower Decksseason 4 stream Thursdays on Paramount+ .
